Reviews
Part of How to plan a quiet desk setup before buying a single accessory
Reversible ways to make a desk setup in a rented room quieter and more comfortable
Reversible changes for a desk in a rented room: placement, mats, pads, screen height, seating, and what not to try when the lease limits wall fixings.
Renting removes most of the standard advice. You cannot alter the floor, you probably cannot fix anything to the wall, and the room is doing three jobs already. What is left is furniture, placement and mass, which turns out to be a longer list than it sounds.
What to take away
- Every useful change here is reversible. If it needs a screw in the structure, it is a different project.
- Where the desk sits in the room matters more than what the desk is made of.
- A sofa or a chair without a backrest is the most common real problem, and the cheapest to fix.
- A laptop screen at laptop height is the second.
Where the small-space evidence actually points
A survey of 232 people working from home in Hong Kong, where living space is tight, gives a direct picture. It found that 61.2 percent reported musculoskeletal discomfort while working from home.
Home office discomfort risk
61.2% reported musculoskeletal discomfort
51% worked in living or dining area
About 25% worked in a bedroom
Laptop screen: 2-3x more neck/back risk
Some 51 percent worked in a living or dining area and about a quarter in a bedroom. Using a chair without a backrest, or a sofa, predicted a significantly higher risk of discomfort.
Working on a laptop screen carried roughly two to three times the risk of neck, upper back and lower back discomfort compared with a separate monitor. Read that as a priority list. Seating and screen height come before anything acoustic.
Reversible changes, in order
- Move the desk off the shared wall and out of the corner, since corners reinforce low frequencies.
- Put a dense mat under the keyboard and felt pads under the monitor stand and the desk feet.
- Raise the screen and add a separate keyboard, even if the computer is a laptop.
- Put a bookcase, a wardrobe or anything heavy between you and the wall the complaint comes from.
- Use a rug under the chair rather than a hard mat, which rolls quietly and protects the floor.
- Close the door, and add a draft seal that fits without adhesive if the lease allows it.
Seating in a room with no space for a proper chair
The chair is the hardest thing to solve in a small room, because a good one is large. Read OSHA's guidance on chairs at a computer workstation before spending.
It asks for a backrest that follows the curve of your spine with real lumbar support, and a seat that lets your feet rest flat on the floor or a footrest. Armrests should be soft enough to let your shoulders relax, and the base should have five legs.
It also notes that adjustability matters most when a chair has more than one user, which is the case in a shared flat.
If the chair must be a dining chair, add a cushion for height, a rolled towel for lower back support, and a footrest for your feet. That is not a solution, but it beats a sofa.
What is not worth doing in a rental
Thin foam on a wall will not stop sound reaching the neighbor. A self-adhesive sheet sold as soundproofing will fail or damage paint. The deposit costs more than the panel saved.
The rules that decide this are in how building rules affect a desk setup. The order to try things is in the planning guide.
